Skip to main content

Pacific Trim: In Which We Doctor A Story

Hello friends!  This week I'd like to show you an exercise to help you work on your plot doctoring skills.  I do a lot of critiquing and part of that is considering how satisfactory an overall story is.

It can be difficult to separate yourself from your own story, so I encourage you to start with a story that isn't yours.  For simplicity's sake, I'd also suggest picking a movie.  Most tend to follow a formula and that makes it easy to fit the story-line into a few paragraphs.  If you can make the plot simple to think about, this makes it that much easier to adjust.
pacificrim.wikia.com
For my example, I will be using a movie that came out last year.  This is a movie I loved, but I had major problems with.  I recommend you pick a movie that you take issue with.  If you thought it was perfect, there isn't anything for you to play with.  Unless you decide to make the protagonist decide to have the opposite reaction to the inciting event and then follow that story-line wherever it takes you.  (In which case, go for it, and good luck to you, but you're not doctoring a plot, you're writing a new story with the same beginning.)

Before we begin, I should mention that this is an EXERCISE, so, for fun and for you to develop your writing chops, not for you to profit from.  We don't own the rights to these stories, we are merely using them to build our storyteller strength.  Consider yourself doing fanservice to the story.  Characters, settings, technology will all remain the same.  We are only changing events in an effort to improve the story.  Before you begin, take a look around the internet and see what other kind of fan-fiction exists for the movie you've chosen.  FanFiction.net is a great place to start.  (Still worried about legality?  Give Anma Natsu's podcast about the legality of working with existing stories a listen.)

Synopsis
Okay.  If you haven't figured it out from the title, the movie I'm doctoring today is Pacific Rim.
twitchfilm.com
I don't own the rights to this movie or any of its characters, themes, images, etc.  There is a novelization of the movie by Alexander Irvine, released at the same time the movie went into theaters.  I haven't read it and am concerning myself only with the story portrayed in the movie.  I loved the action and fx in this movie, but I had problems with the story and the science.  Suffice it to say there will be SPOILERS in my discussion of the story.  Here's the synopsis from IDMB.  It's long, so I won't copy-pasta.

Find the synopsis for your movie.  Can't find one?  Watch it again and write your own.  It's important to establish the existing beats of the story before you can go to work on them.  I even added a few extra beats to the above linked synopsis from my re-watch.

Issues
Identify the places that you felt the story fell short.  Don't try and fix anything yet, just figure out where you felt like something was off, or, in some places, completely wrong.  For simplicity's sake, I've left out some of the more nit-picky science issues that I had with the movie.  When giant robots are fighting aliens from another dimension that are actually relations to the dinosaurs, science becomes hand-waving to a certain extent.  That's why it's a sci-fi.  I identified about 27 initially and cut down over a third of those that can be corrected with simple science and really don't affect the story.  I left in a couple here in this list that really annoy me, though so that you can come out smarter on the other side of this.
fanboy.com
1. Awkward infodump at beginning.
2. Pilot on the right side of the cockpit controls the right side of the Jager.
3. Pilots inside the Drift speak aloud to each other and separately, even asking each other questions and arguing.
4. Jagers don’t have readings of kaiju signatures.
5. Wall Of Life - it is never clear where along the coast the wall is, whether closer to land or the rift (shots from report in Sydney make it look like close to coastline).
6. Pentecost introduces Raleigh to the two scientists under their command.
7. Austrailian team (Striker Eureka) the only other team with character development besides Raleigh and Mako.
8. Fighting trials done with staves.
9. Following the incident, Raleigh understands more about Mako and Pentecost.  Not even the slightest bit pissed at Mako.
10. Raleigh doesn’t get mad at Pentecost for knowingly putting him into that situation, even tries to take the blame.
11. EMP knocks out Striker Eureka and Shatterdome, but city remains lit up.
12. With 2 hours until the system can be rebooted, Striker Eureka is dead in the water until Raleigh gives a solution: though the newer models of Jaeger are digital, the Gypsy Danger is analog and thus more resistant to EMP attacks.
13. Raleigh had no idea there was a sword in Gypsy Danger, even though he’s drifted with Mako and is connected to the machine.
14. Shatterdome has lights and radio despite EMP and two hours have not elapsed.
15. Mako and Raleigh are on separate oxygen supplies.
16. Somehow Gypsy Danger and the Shatterdome can communicate from opposite sides of the drift.
17. Halfway through breach, Raleigh ejects Mako in a life pod and manually initiates the detonation of the nuclear core.
18. Raleigh's pod somehow makes it through breach.

Figure Out Why You Take Issue
A beat in a movie could be weird due to bad acting, not the story itself, so try and figure out why you have a problem before you decide to change anything.  I found a few places where I felt that Pacific Rim could have been improved by subbing in a different lead.  Charlie Hunnam is nice for eye candy and action, but his acting chops aren't as strong.  I've left out the issues I had with him alone.
CinemaBlend
1. An info-dump is a tell, not a show.  Plus it's boring, even if it is establishing backstory.
2. Allowing for some hand-waving science, this is still wrong.  The right side of the brain controls the left side of the body.
3. & 13. We were told that the drift is a total melding of minds, so if the pilots speak aloud it should be in unison, and if you and another human being are sharing a mind, there shouldn't be any room for confusion or disagreement.
4. It makes no sense for mission control to be talking the Jagers through the fights.  If mission control can read the "Kaiju Signature" (glossing over how that's possible), then the Jagers should have that ability as well.
5. Barring off the entire Pacific would cause serious economic and ecosystem disruption.
6. Only two.  Even though there are a million people walking by all the time in the Shatterdome.
7. This should be a no-brainer. The Russian (Cherno Alpha) and Chinese (Crimson Typhoon) teams are there to look awesome and then die. We don't care about their deaths, and neither does anyone else seem to at the Shatterdome. I was mostly upset that I didn't get to see more three-armed fighting as opposed to feeling the loss of five Jager pilots and two Jagers. With two less Jagers, the plan to detonate the Rift should be in more jeopardy, but we don't get any trepidation from the teams or anyone on base.
8. Jagers fight by boxing and ammo, with the occasional melee weapon thrown in.
9. Mako almost killed a ton of technicians on base, would also be causing severe damage to the hanger and other Jagers. Raleigh's memory of his brother's death came back fresh once he stepped into the drift, so that will be upsetting him. And Raleigh couldn't pull Mako out of the rabbit hole, so he could be taking out some of his frustration over that on her as well.
10. Pentecost knew this was a risk and let Mako in the cockpit anyway.
11. Allowing that this was a localized pulse, the Shatterdome is right next to the city. At least the buildings next to the harbor should be knocked offline.
12.  That is not how EMP's or nuclear power works.  (This is a pdf report from Oak Ridge National Laboratory on HEMP, see the appendix on page 167 for explanation of misconceptions.)  The EMP can still cause damage to Gypsy Danger because the Jager has electronic wiring and interfacing throughout.  She runs on nuclear power, but that does no good if the power can't travel anywhere in the machine.
14. Obvious sign is obvious.
15. It makes no sense for there to be two separate O2 supplies in the Jager.  They have separate lines, so in order for damage to occur on Mako's and not on Raleigh's, the cockpit would have to be breached, and it wasn't.  And why don't they have an emergency 5-15 minute supply in their suits?  They are fighting at the bottom of the ocean, for crying out loud!
16. This is just laughable.
17. Shouldn't have to because of #15, also this gives Raleigh the finishing blow even though Mako has been the one working so hard for it the entire movie.  Raleigh has almost no character development in this movie, so his victory doesn't feel as big.
18. No Kaiju DNA!

Possible Fixes
Give yourself some options when it comes to fixes.  Look for fixes that don't upset the world of the story (e.g. no cell phones in GOT).  Bonus points if you can use an existing feature of the story to solve a problem in the plot.  (Hate the eagles plot hole in LOTR?  Check this out.)
pacificrim.wikia.com
There are two major problems that we can see carried throughout the story.  1. Bad science. 2. Insufficient character development.  I'm going to try to fix both at once.

1. Given, this is a movie, and it can be harder to weave in backstory than it is in a novel.  I think they should have skipped the narration and settled for a series of cut scenes between the news reports with CC's of dates.
2. Switch the pilot sides OR say that the pilot on the right controls the left side of the robot.
3. & 13. Make the pilots speak in unison when in the drift, and if they have to argue, have their voices do it "mentally".
4. Give the Jagers a reading on the Kaiju Signature.
5. Move the wall out farther from the coast, make it semipermiable so that small animals can get through.
6. Give them a few assistants, or maybe just one who's interested in both fields.  That would give some more comic relief as they both boss the assistant around.
7. We see the Tang brothers (Crimson Typhoon team) playing basketball in a fleeting glance, but they don't have any spoken lines.  After Mako nearly destroys the Shatterdome in their first drift, could have Raleigh go blow off some steam with the brothers in a game of horse.  This gives the brothers some opportunities to ham it up and show us their personalities.
The Kaidonofskys (Cherno Alpha) do get to say exciting things similar to "Rodger", "Engage", and then scream in agony as they die.  But otherwise they're in the background.  Give them a small scene as well to make them seem more like real people.
Thirdly, have a scene where Gypsy and Striker are being fitted for their trip to the rift after Crimson Typhoon and Cherno Alpha go down.  Have Chuck Hansen, the son in Striker team pair, come check on how progress is going on re-fitting Striker since the EMP would have blown out all the capacitors.  He's all cocky and superior, his usual self.  Technicians from Crimson and Cherno have been conscripted to help make the deadline, and one or a few of them remind Chuck that if it wasn't for Pentecost's orders, he'd likely be at the bottom of the bay instead of the other pilots.  This makes us feel the death of the other crews more and helps chip away at the arrogance of Chuck so that we believe and can support his sacrifice at the end of the movie.
8. Have them do more MMA style fighting in the trials.  Or laser tag!!
9. Have Raleigh chew out Mako for bringing that history into the drift and not giving him a heads up first.  Then have them be pissed at another since Raleigh screwed up also.
10. Have Raleigh chew out Pentecost for letting Mako in the drift with him and not giving him fair warning.  Then Pentecost can still do the "1. Do not ever touch me again. 2. Do not ever touch me again," bit.
11, 12, & 14. Shrink the EMP so that only Striker Eureka is affected.  The "fact" that Gypsy is "analog" and shouldn't be affected by the EMP is kind of pointless (besides out and out wrong, hence the use of quotes), since Gypsy Danger goes and pulls the EMP producing organ off of the Kaiju first thing and it only ever got to deploy the one pulse.  The Shatterdome can stay up and functional since they pretty much have a sportscaster function in the fights and just give us a play by play.
Raleigh and Mako are deployed to protect the city and have to overcome their differences to initiate the mental handshake.  Can have the mental handshake be shaky at first, but then hold firm when the pilots accept their own emotions and the emotions of each other.  This gives us more character development for Raleigh who is mopey at the beginning of the story and then kind of on a "I'll just go with the flow" plateau afterwards.
15 & 17. Have both of their O2 supplies be damaged, that way it serves the "ticking time bomb" function but they both have something to .  They can set the manual self-destruct together and have a "for my brother," "for my family," "for Pentecost," "for the world," cheesy moment.  Only probably more epic and less cheesy.  Escape pods can deploy at the same time.
16. Eliminate and just have the Shatterdome have nothing until they see the rift collapsing, then they have to sit on their hands to find out if the pilots make it out okay.
18. The rift reads anything passing through from our world to the other side to make sure that only Kaiju can go through, so it would make sense to work both ways.  Have the pilots be unsure if their pods will go back through, but have there be enough Kaiju blood/bodily fluids on the outside of Gypsy Danger that the pods have some on them and can pass through as well, but we (audience) don't find out until the last second when the pods make it through.  I would also put the rift on the ground in the "anteverse".

Test Your Theories
Make sure that your fix doesn't break the rest of the story.  Re-read the synopsis with your fixes subbed in.  Does the story still make sense?  Do you feel that you improved the story or did you just pick another placeholder for the problem?  If it's #2, go back through the process again.
Scified
Once you are satisfied, step back and breathe deep.  You've improved a story.  You've made the world a better place.  You should be proud!  Now you can take this strategy to your own story when you're going through edits, or when you're critiquing someone else's story.  I would caution against offering fixes to someone else.  Unless you've been asked for possible solutions, I'd stop after issues and whys.  Authors see stories as their children, and can turn Mama Bear if they feel like you've overstepped your boundaries.
Nerdspan
What movies would you like to fix?  Share in the comments.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

February Post

Give me a break, I hate coming up with titles.

And the FCC spoke and said, 'Verily, I say unto thee, Verizon and their ilk shall not throttle the bandwidth of those they despise, nor shall they profit from the favoring of entities with greater bandwidth therein.' And there was great rejoicing.  And by great rejoicing, I mean that the internet blew up arguing about what color a dress was.  You go, America, exercise that freedom.

Girls and boys, it's the last Friday in February and I haven't posted anything this month, so here goes.

I'm so glad I didn't try to keep posting weekly, because school owns my life nowadays.  I approve of the once-a-month plan so far.  We'll see if I can do more posts during my summer break (i.e. the month of May).

As you might have guessed, I have not done any editing on Om Nom Nombies.  I haven't written anything more on the first drafts of The Neif or Spitfire.  I haven't even made any progress beta-ing a manuscript for m…

Non-Traditional Plot Structure

Happy Friday friends!  This post is about plot:  what we traditionally think of as plot, and what other options exist in the world.

For starters, let's define the difference between plot and narrative structure.  Plot is (loosely) the events that happen in the story.  Narrative structure is the order readers experience the story events.  Ingrid Sundberg does a good job of differentiating the two here.  (May as well open that up in a new tab and leave it open, I'm going to be referencing her blog a lot today.  She's pretty much already done what I wanted to do with this post.)

If your public education was like mine, you were probably introduced to a figure similar to this somewhere in your English classes:
This is the standard plot that we can fit most stories into.  This describes a plot centered around conflict that follows a traditional three-act structure.  It's very popular.  In the Middle reviews a book that discusses using this structure as a form for your story, an…

Head Games: The Next Project

I am ecstatic to announce my next project, Head Games!

 The origin story on this one is a bit mussed.  I've been sitting on this idea since before I started writing Spitfire, so, a few years.
I was contemplating the Hulk one afternoon, as one does.  It makes sense that he gets giant and violent when he's angry (unless you buy that he's always angry), but I never got why he turned green.  I started thinking about what emotions would look like as superpowers.  I imagined a little girl literally glowing with joy, reading a book by her own light under the covers long after her bedtime.  And it kept going from there.  But most powers were painful in their first showing.  For example, a flash of light from a burst of joy would blind anyone close enough.

So I have a group of people with emotional superpowers.  But they're also super messed up because of what happened when their powers first showed.  And anyone who is ever been told to smile knows that you don't get to t…