Skip to main content

Filtering through critiques

Happy Friday, friends!

Over the past few weeks, I've been thinking about feedback that I've gotten on my pieces and feedback I've seen others receive.  If you're a relatively new writer, or at least new to getting critiques, it can be difficult to receive critiques with grace.  What's even more difficult is figuring out if what you've gotten back is useful.  Here's how I evaluate my feedback to decide what advice and suggestions to keep, and what to discard.

1) Is this person in my target audience?
Your target audience is a rough approximation of the demographic that you see being a fan of your work.  Whether it's YA, something geared more for baby boomers, whatever, you should have a pretty good idea about who this is by the time you're getting feedback, if not before you start writing.  If they are in your target audience, give their suggestions greater weight.

2) Is this person a fan of other works in this genre?
This goes along the same lines as above.  If they are fans of hard SF and that's what you're shooting for, pay special attention to what they have to say.

3) How much writing experience does this person have?
This goes more along the technical side, but if they have been writing for several years, they might have more insight to offer as far as plot fixes.

4) If you've read anything that this person has written, are you a fan of their work?
This one you might be able to take or leave.  Just because a person doesn't write something you would pay money for doesn't mean they won't have good insight for your story.  However, I would take what they say with a grain of salt.  Often times, (I find myself doing this) a critiquer will read a piece through the lens of their own style, so keep that in mind when you read their feedback.

5) What is this person's background outside of writing?
Maybe they don't like to read the genre that your story falls into, but they have kids, so they spend lots of time with tiny people in the two to seven years old.  If your story has kids in it in that range, listen to their feedback!  Or maybe they're in the medical field, or law enforcement, or the IT world.  If they have insight on something and they're offering to share that with your story, take it!

So, what if, at the end of the day, the answer to one or more of these questions is "yes" and you still don't like the feedback you are getting?  You don't ever have to change your story.  If multiple people have problems with the same character or turn of events in your story, you should consider their feedback.  But remember that this is your story.  You know what kind of story you want it to be.  Your opinion is the one that is the most important.


Popular posts from this blog

Non-Traditional Plot Structure

Happy Friday friends!  This post is about plot:  what we traditionally think of as plot, and what other options exist in the world.

For starters, let's define the difference between plot and narrative structure.  Plot is (loosely) the events that happen in the story.  Narrative structure is the order readers experience the story events.  Ingrid Sundberg does a good job of differentiating the two here.  (May as well open that up in a new tab and leave it open, I'm going to be referencing her blog a lot today.  She's pretty much already done what I wanted to do with this post.)

If your public education was like mine, you were probably introduced to a figure similar to this somewhere in your English classes:
This is the standard plot that we can fit most stories into.  This describes a plot centered around conflict that follows a traditional three-act structure.  It's very popular.  In the Middle reviews a book that discusses using this structure as a form for your story, an…

February Post

Give me a break, I hate coming up with titles.

And the FCC spoke and said, 'Verily, I say unto thee, Verizon and their ilk shall not throttle the bandwidth of those they despise, nor shall they profit from the favoring of entities with greater bandwidth therein.' And there was great rejoicing.  And by great rejoicing, I mean that the internet blew up arguing about what color a dress was.  You go, America, exercise that freedom.

Girls and boys, it's the last Friday in February and I haven't posted anything this month, so here goes.

I'm so glad I didn't try to keep posting weekly, because school owns my life nowadays.  I approve of the once-a-month plan so far.  We'll see if I can do more posts during my summer break (i.e. the month of May).

As you might have guessed, I have not done any editing on Om Nom Nombies.  I haven't written anything more on the first drafts of The Neif or Spitfire.  I haven't even made any progress beta-ing a manuscript for m…

12 Ways Wonder Woman Was Actually An Anime

Clickbait title?  Riding the coattails of a hugely successful franchise?


So, Wonder Woman has been insanely successful.  It had some cool stuff going on but was not my favorite movie.  I had several problems with it, mostly happening after Diana leaves Themyscira.  But I'm going to put most of them aside to talk about why Wonder Woman was actually an anime, despite being live action, full of white people, and made by 'Merica.

I'm working on the assumption that you've seen anime before in a quantity sufficient to familiarize yourself with its tropes, so I'm not going to go into detail about why these are tropes and how long they've been around.  Also going to assume you've seen Wonder Woman and not going to worry about whether I'm spoiling anything for you.

Blessed From Birth
From birth Diana is special.  She's the only child on her island and basically does whatever she wants.
Like lots of chosen ones.

Accidental Boob Grab
Okay, that's…